Nose:Surprisingly fresh and lifted.Aromatic with a gentle spiciness dominating.Some ‘whisky rancio’ and in time spearmint.Clean but deep.
Palate:Slightly musty (which is only to be expected) Bone dry with oak showing. Balsa wood. Venerable but light.
Finish:Surprisingly creamy.Date:1953 53.7% sherry butt
Nose:Leather and Seville orange/marmalade.Funky and fungal Rich,Sultana and leather upholstery.
Palate:Fine grip and not too tannic with some light sweet spice (nutmeg).Raisin. Good feel. Slightly fragile but with almost meaty weight.
Finish:Long,gripping.Date:1954 52.6% sherry butt
Nose:Lush and smooth. Chestnut liqueur. Distictly nutty but the impression is this is balanced by silky depth.Bitter orange.
Palate:The mix of sweet raisined depth and savoury nuttiness makes it reminiscent of Brandy de Jerez. Powerful and deep.Clove.
Finish:Burnt,treacle like.Date:1955 46.1% sherry butt
Nose:Little distant.Most overtly oaky.Bitter
chocolate.Opens into liqueur chocolate,black
cherry/Black Forest gateau.Leathery as it develops.
Palate:Dry.Tree bark Firm tannins but with good
length.Cherry again.
Finish:Gripping.Date:1956 47.3% sherrybutt
Nose:Dryoloroso [cheese rind,walnut,raisin,horse
flanks].There’s a smoked quality as well bringing to
mind a spentbonfire.Molasses.Bittersweet.
Palate:Lightly fragrant.Rose.Quite dusty tannins
and then a meaty/stock cube note.
Finish:Sooty.Date:1957 54% sherry hogshead
Nose:Incredibly dark.Opaque.Very intense shifting
into balsamic/soy territory.Savoury,dense.That old
leather note once more.
Layered brooding and powerful.
Palate:The savoury edge is dominant here.Is this
whisky any more or has it evolved into some new
densely flavoured beast? A light lift on the back
palate.1956 in reverse.
Finish:Slightly bitter.Date:1958 51.6% sherrybutt
Nose:Black as pitch and similar on the nose.Tar and
treacle toffee,Xmas cake,mixed nuts (burnt almond).
darkmintchocolate.Huge.
Palate:Aprune likesweetness and richness
balancing the immense weight of the oak.Firm but
goodbalance.
Finish:Long.Date:1959 52.5% sherry hogshead
Nose:Touch of sulphur. Roasted.Rooty and deep.
Liqourice (Pontefract cake) Big and powerful with a
sense of tannic grip.leaf mulch,dried fig.
Palate:Very firm and grippy.Old dried flowers,oak
truffle and leather.
Finish:Dries then dies.60s
Date:1960 52.4% sherry hogshead
Nose:Vinous.Black fruits Cigar box.It’s a classic old
style Barolo,all tar and roses.Fragrant and wildly
exotic.Hint of varnish.
Palate: Incense.Very graceful and a real change from
the robust power of the 1950s.Camphor.
Finish:Long and scented.Like a charming,if slightly
batty,old lady.Date:1961 46% sherry hogshead
Nose:Abalanced marriage between the
burnt/roasted notes and an almost feral sweetness.
Coffee and polished oak.Bourbon biscuits.
Palate:Again a lifted aroma (is this a 60s style
emerging?) Chocolate and charred wood.The oaky
grip has lifted an real elegant distillery character is
allowed to show.
Finish: Elegant long.Date:1962 54.8% sherry hogshead
Nose:Straight back to 1959.Dundee cake,cooking
chocolate,raisin and prune.Little dumb.
Palate:Very grippy.Huge cask influence.Stewed tea
leaves.Classic sherry bomb.
Finish:Tight.
Date:1963 56.7% sherry butt
Nose:Lifted.Pure sweet oloroso aromas (sim to 56,
but sweeter).Complex with a biscuity warmth.
Sultana,walnut,tree bark,powerful,dusty and herbal
in time.
Palate:Good mix of light soy sauce resinous oak and
griping tannins.
Finish:Firm and long.Date:1964 53.1% sherrybutt
Nose:Slicker than 63.If it were a sherry it would be a
cream.Fresh orange peel,tanned hides.Slightly
animalistic with a meaty edge/gravy browning.
Palate:More sweet and direct than ’63.Beautifully
balanced for such a big whisky.Grip on the tongue.
Yew trees sandalwood.
Finish:Long and lifted.Date:1965 60% sherry butt
Nose:In a line with 60/61.Lighter with a fascinating
perfumed note.Black fruits,some soot,floral,light
spices,balsamic/light soy.Complex.
Palate:Mink oil.Soft and tongue-clinging.Black
bean sauce,coffee grounds.Multi-layered.
Finish:PX sweetness.One of the real stars.Date:1966 51.5% sherrybutt
Nose:Slightly dull after the stellar ’65.A little foosty,
bung cloth and spent cigar butt.Strangely a
fragrance like Edinburgh rock then comes through.
Tannins and stock cubes (this mix of meat and
perfume seems characteristic of this decade’s
examples)
Palate:Moreplacid and easy going than previous
examples.Thick.
Finish:Chewy.Good but not top of the class.Date:1967 58.5% sherry hogshead
Nose:Apowerful vanillin note shifting into nuts and
cream.Walnut whips? In time boot polish.
Palate:On the verge of being too cloying the nut
and cream liqueur quality.Better with water which
calms this quality down and bring out a mushroom
like depth.
Finish:Sweet and clean.Date:1968 65.1% sherry butt
Nose:Back to the feral note of the early 60s.
Liquorice again,also a hint of sulphur.Humidor.In
time there’s porcini mushroom liquor.
Palate:Light sulphur note.Fairly tight to begin with
then shifts to fig.Water improves it.
Finish: Italian woods:hazelnut,Nutella?!Date:1969 56.2% sherry hogshead
Nose:Polished oak and freshly polished at that.
Luscious and sweet.Some cordite,creosote and
plum.Charming in a big-boned fashion.
Palate:Rounded and lightly smoky.Very thick but a
little dumb.
Finish: Lacks expressiveness.70sDate:1970 53.6% sherry butt
Nose:Twiggy/dry leaves,charcoal.Some vanilla.
Needs time to open which is does rather beautifully.
Coffee steam.
Palate:Good balance between the wooded notes
and a basic beefy sweetness.
Finish:Long and quite lush.Date:1971 57.1% sherry butt
Nose:Similar to ’70.A return to a woody nuttiness
burntnotes.High oak extract.An earthy note for the
first time.Blackberry.
Palate:Quitesoft with a prickle of dusty hedgerow
fruits/leaf.Fruit compote.
Finish:Very long.Date:1972 51.1% sherry butt
Nose:Pale.Charred steak,wax,smoke coming
through.The mintiness of the 50s returns.
Little harsh.
Palate:Adense flavourful spirit but the oak has had
little interaction.The two elements still sitting apart
from each other.
Finish:Fruity!Date:1973 58.8% sherry butt
Nose:Similar to ’69 on the nose with extra prune.
Red fruits,some earthy power.Tobacco.
Armagnac like.
Palate:Excellent.Balances light top notes with some
spice and the resonance of age.
Finish: Dry,.then a late burst of fruit.Date:1974 60.8% sherry butt
Nose:Clean with slight burnt notes.Autumn fruits
cut with a surprising grassiness.
The charred note returns alongside polished brass,
butteriness and brambles.
Palate:Sweet powerful and jammy Light nutmeg.
Finish:Layered and long.Date:1975 51.4% refill hogshead
Nose:Slick,smooth,brandy butter melting on a
Christmas pudding.Even smoother with water.
Palate:Soft and sweet with toffee and a balancing
dry bracken note.Herbal.
Finish:Biscuity (chocolate digsestive)Date:1976 49.4% refill butt
Nose:Rater plain and hay like to start.
There’s depth but not quite knitted.Cream and raisin
and a hint of plasticene.
Palate:Alight drift of smoke across the palate along
with wet leather.Slightly dank.
Finish:Peanuts!Date:1977 59% refill butt
Nose:Very pale quite sweet and sherberty.Very
different distillery character emerging here.
Lemon.Light and more in line with
estery Speysiders.
Palate:Clean with good feel.Gentle and a move
into jasmine.A-typical but a good dram.
Finish:Fresh and light.Date:1978 50.3% refill hogshead
Nose:Dry and slightly lean.The nuttiness comes
back.macadamia this time some dried peach and
some malt.
Palate:Sweet with touch of sultana lurking in the
background.Everything has gone lighter.More refill
casks,but also a change in distillation? The whisky
trade was feeingl the pinch around this time.
Finish:Fresh and clean.Date:1979 52.8% plain hogshead
Nose:Pale and slightly neutral.Bubblegum (those
esters again) Chewy.Bananas.
Palate:Thin and slightly abrasive.
Finish:Tart.80sDate:1980 50.1% refill sherry butt
Nose:Some colour.Chestnut mushroom.Quite
light.Cooked apple.Fairly firm.Nut oils.
Palate:Back to bigger European oak influence.
Tannins but balanced by a lifted distillate.balanced.
Finish:Cigar box.Date:1981 52.4% refill sherry hogshead
Nose:Lightand zesty.Yeast and a hint of white
pepper.Polished oak,anise,sawdust and clean.
Good depth with water.
Palate:Clean with a citric zing.Lightly spiced.Has
brio.Silky
Finish:Spiced cider.Date:1982 58.3% refill sherry hogshead
Nose:Light coffee/vegetal notes along with a hint
of glue shifting into a waxiness.
Palate:Slightly unformed.Lightly acidic then a
sudden spiced lift on the back palate.
Finish:Clean quite short.Date:1983 56% refill hogshead
Nose:Pale and buttery/clotted cream.Always that
burnt/roasted character underneath. Raffia lemon
and lychee.Singed.Even more buttery with water.
Palate:The wood is in charge.Butterscotch.
Finish:Slightly flabby.Date:1984 51.3% plain hogshead
Nose:The most charred of all.Spent fire touch of
plastic.Some leather (pigskin)
Palate:Thin and rather lean.
Finish:Tight.Date:1985 46.3% refill sherry hogshead
Nose:Suddenly more cask influence.Moist fruit
cake,light dried fruit.Very pure and fruity.Apple and
blackberry pie filling.
Palate:Alighter style of Glenfarclas but rather
subtle and smooth.Soft caramel.
Coming back to form.
Finish:Clean medium,toasted.Date:1986 56.5% refill sherry puncheon
Nose:Dry oak and rich spirit.Dusty flour.Touch of
sulphur.Much better with water.Toasted tea cake.
Palate: Higher tannins than the last few.Sweet
spices and the pepperines of youth.Has the
luscious leathery depth you expect.
Finish:Long full and fruity.Date:1987 55.1% refill sherry hogshead
Nose:Deeper in colour.Another winey one this
time almost syrah like:black fruit and soot
alongside toffee apple and chestnut honey.
Palate:The tannis are back but the fruit is sufficient
to balance.Great depth.Glenfarclas is back!
Finish:Ripe and full.Date:1988 56.3% sherry butt
Nose:Rich colour.Quite crisp.Needs water,which
brings out figs and reduces an acetone note.
Darjeeling tea,some fragrance.
Palate:Light concentration.Flavours have shifted
around to apple but the liquorice of old now makes
acomeback.An interesting battle.
Finish:Crisp and toasty.Date:1989 60% sherry butt
Nose:Sulphur/spent firework with chewy fruits,
with added resin.Has power.
Palate:Rich and robust with good tannic grip.
Finish:Dense.90sDate:1990 58.9% sherry butt
Nose:Rich and very complex.Sweet yet fresh.Very
good balance.Herbs,mint and caramel.Lacquer.
Drift of sulphur adding a lift to the aroma.
Palate:Soft start,moist fruit loaf touch of ginger.
balancing tannins.
Finish:Long.Figgy.Date:1991 57.9% sherry butt
Nose:Compared to 1990 this has even more sultry
sweetness.Very chewy,like Highland toffee.Some
burnt sugar in there as well.Stewed fruit.
Palate:Substantial and full.Glenfarclas re-emerges
after what appears to have been a tricky decade.
Finish:Long thick.Date:1992 55.5% sherry butt
Nose:Slightly paler but again the impact is huge.
The meaty/leatheriness seems to have been
replaced by toffee mixed with a signed character
underneath.Touch of cut grass and vanilla.
Palate:Good burnt/savoury character.Good
extract but almost needs more time in wood.
Finish:Coming together.Date:1993 58.9% refill sherry butt
Nose:Mocha/cafe latte! Sweetness and creaminess
to the fore.Quite simple and sweet with good
weight.In time a lot of sulphur.
Palate:Big sulphur and big grip.
Finish:Quite tough.Date:1994 59.6% sherry butt
Nose:Now the hard toffee has become runny.Big
and generous.Sprig of thyme and a whiff of mint.
Silky and long.
Palate:Quite perfumed.A triumphant finish to a
remarkable tale.This shows complexity and the
layered quality of the finest old examples where
mix of savouryand sweet gives depth and interest.
Finish:Long with a surprising lift of dried lime.