One of One: this auction of £3.1 million worth of unique Scotch took 'old and rare' whisky to a new level

One of One: this auction of £3.1 million worth of unique Scotch took 'old and rare' whisky to a new level

It's no surprise that the Distillers’ One of One charity auction raised £2.45 million for charity — each lot was unique

Whisky Talk & Happenings | 27 Mar 2022 | Issue 181 | By Christopher Coates

  • Share to:
Friday 3 December 2021 saw the culmination of a dream more than 20 years in the making and the evolution of the Worshipful Company of Distillers’ ongoing 383-year philanthropic mission. Granted a Royal Charter in 1638, the Distillers is one of 110 City of London livery companies created to represent specific industries in the capital. Today, the Livery is made up of members from across the world of spirits and, along with its function as an industry social and networking organisation, pursues key objectives including the support of spirits education, vocational training and numerous charitable causes, especially those that benefit young people.

Held at Barnbougle Castle near South Queensferry, The Distillers’ One of One auction, a partnership between the Distillers, Sotheby’s and 37 Scotch whisky makers, delivered total sales of £3.1 million (2.5 times the low estimate) and raised more than £2.45 million for charity in the process. Offering bidders the chance to purchase truly one-off experiences, bottles and casks of rare whisky, it is no overstatement to say that neither the auction world, nor the world of Scotch whisky, has ever seen its equal.
Harry Dalmeny, chairman of Sotheby’s UK & Ireland

Pivotally, 100 per cent of the hammer price achieved by each of the auction’s 42 unique lots, along with a portion of Sotheby’s buyer’s premium, will be donated to The Distillers’ Charity’s Youth Action Fund, a completely new initiative which aims to transform the lives of disadvantaged young people in Scotland by aiding their journey into meaningful employment and helping them to make a positive contribution to their communities. That 37 competitors would come together in the spirit of charity is laudable; that those same rivals would freely donate some of their most rare and valuable spirits in the name of communal endeavour is nothing short of inspiring.

“The roads to Barnbougle have been many and varied, but have really now come together,” says Jonathan Driver, immediate past master of the Worshipful Company of Distillers and managing director for private clients at William Grant & Sons. Driver shares that, though the practical efforts of the past year to create The Distillers’ One of One auction were pivotal, it was truly made possible by work begun over 20 years ago to re-engage the Livery with the distilling industry and re-invigorate its sense of purpose.
Bidding at the auction

When he joined the Distillers more than two decades ago, Driver explains only a small proportion of liverymen were current or past members of the distilling trade, and most of those were retired. Today, over 90 per cent of members are actively employed in the spirits industry and the average age of members is decreasing year on year. Beyond simply changing the make-up of the Livery, Driver says this evolution of its membership has brought with it a new sense of purpose.

Under the stewardship of past master Brian Morrison, formerly of Morrison Bowmore Distillers and today the head of Morrison Scotch Whisky Distillers, the Livery launched its first charity whisky auction in 2013. “He said we could raise £100,000 – everyone said he was mad,” recalls Driver. Nevertheless, Morrison’s faith in the industry was well placed. Run entirely by volunteers, the inaugural Livery whisky auction raised a quarter of a million pounds. “Overnight, the Livery had undergone a quantum shift.”
Jamie Ritchie, head of Sotheby’s Wine

This success led to another volunteer-run auction in 2018 that raised over £220,000. However, the team noticed that it was the unique items – the ‘one of ones’ – put under the hammer that attracted the most attention. Early discussions with Sotheby’s spirits specialist Jonny Fowle led to the auction house presenting a 60-page proposal, which outlined how the Distillers’ auction could be elevated from a moderately successful, in-house affair to a globally recognised philanthropic event that would court both headlines and sky-high bidding in aid of a good cause.

“It was a defining moment for the Livery,” says Driver. “We had an amazing membership; amazing links to the industry; we’d done similar before, so we knew what would or wouldn’t work; and a partner on board. So, we said, ‘Why don’t we just try to create this?’”
Enjoying a dram between the Callum Innes cask end and Bowmore Onyx

The proposal was welcomed by the Court of Assistants in winter 2020, and, thus, The Distillers’ One of One auction was born. All that remained was the small task of making the idea become reality. “We only got real agreement in the spring of this year [2021] for most of them to do it,” Driver says of the participating distillers, before lauding the phenomenal effort they all put in to create entirely unique offerings in time for the December 2021 auction date. “We’ve done it all in six months. It’s unbelievable.”

In many companies, preparing lots for The Distillers’ One of One auction required working outside of standard procedures and generously dedicating hundreds of hours (not to mention open cheque books) to the delivery of lots that would attract the crème de la crème of global whisky collectors – connoisseurs that Sotheby’s know well.

“At Sotheby’s, we’re all about the very best provenance, and direct from distillers is the very best,” says Jamie Ritchie, worldwide head of Sotheby’s Wine, adding that three key qualities underpin all of the Distillers’ One of One lots. “Consumers nowadays want a couple of different things: they want unique things, they want experiences they can’t have elsewhere, and they want access to people.”
Littlemill Testament 1976

What’s more, especially as concerns ultra-rare bottles that may never be opened, it’s important that buyers have the chance to taste the same liquid housed inside the unique bottle (or cask) they’ve bought. “You present ‘one of one’, but with enough liquid for someone to be able to enjoy it aside from the package… but then you need the sample to stay with it,” adds Ritchie. By partnering directly with distillers that can (within reason) supply additional samples, this auction is also unique in that it allows buyers to have their cake and eat it too.

The day before the auction, members of the Livery felt that achieving £2 million would be a dream come true – to exceed this by another million was a pipe dream. Yet, that’s exactly what was achieved.
The Balvenie 1964

“There was a whole euphoria that you could sense at the end of the auction. We’ve been inundated with messages from everybody saying how happy they are with the outcome,” says Grant Gordon, committee chair at The Distillers’ Charity, which was founded in 1955 to support young people from disadvantaged backgrounds and to help provide vocational training and education to the next generation entering the spirits trade.

“The mission of the Youth Action Fund is to transform the life chances of 16 to 25-year-old people in Scotland… our target is to initially reach over 1,000 young people and then grow significantly from there,” adds Gordon. The Fund will initially support four charities: Aberdeen Foyer, ENABLE Scotland, Street League, and the Alcohol Education Trust. For the Livery, success means that each person the charities work with will enter stable, meaningful employment.
The Glen Garioch casks auctioned in a bespoke cradle

“It’s quite specific and it’s quite tangible… for families that have been out of work for multiple generations, it can be that one person who gets that meaningful job that can break that family away from the cycle of poverty,” says Gordon. “What an opportunity we have now. We have much more resource than, frankly, we’d hoped for. So, hopefully we’ll be able to go quite far with this.”
Bowmore Onyx

The Charities

Aberdeen Foyer
helps people in the North East of Scotland towards independent living, learning and work. Working with more than 1,600 people a year, the Foyer starts with people’s strengths, supporting them to build their confidence, develop their talents and make real and lasting change in their lives. The Foyer delivers joined-up services offering supported housing, learning, training, counselling, employment support and health-improvement initiatives to young people and adults.

ENABLE Scotland
aims to create an equal society for every person with a learning disability. Through its grassroots and national campaigning, it is committed to amplifying the voices of people with learning disabilities and their families. Each year, it directly supports more than 1,000 people across Scotland’s local authorities to be local activists; get specialist information, advice and advocacy; access community-based support; and lead campaigns for change.

Street League
uses the power of sport to tackle poverty and give young people the opportunities they need to succeed in life and the workplace. From school to the world of work, this charity works with young people aged 14–30, living in the UK’s most disadvantaged communities. Street League’s staff help these young people overcome their practical and personal barriers to employment by giving them the chance to develop in a proactive environment without the pressure of traditional teaching methods.

The Alcohol Education Trust
is a small, focused charity which works across the UK to keep young people safe around alcohol. It is a leading early-intervention charity that helps young people aged 11–25 to make more informed life choices through the 4,500 schools and youth organisations it supports, free of charge, via its award-winning resources and training. The charity works to support parents, carers, teachers and community leaders.
Artist Callum Innes and his bespoke cask end, created to accompany the Talisker 1978 Cask of Distinction

Significant Lots

Bowmore Onyx:
Matured in an American oak refill barrel, which was filled on 17 February 1970, this single malt was the first 51-year-old whisky ever released by Islay’s oldest active whisky distillery. A work of art in its own right, the hand-blown decanter holds 1.4 litres of rare whisky and was created by studio Glasstorm. The bottle, a striking functional sculpture, has been crafted to evoke the geology of Islay – specifically, the distinctive black rock, or ‘bogha mor’, from which it is believed the name Bowmore is derived. Onyx achieved a record price of £400,000.

Talisker Cask of Distinction 1978:
Donated by Diageo and part of its exclusive cask ownership programme, Casks of Distinction, this was the highest-value cask sold at the auction and achieved a final price of £625,000. This still-maturing cask of rare, 43-year-old whisky distilled in 1978 at the famous distillery on Skye was paired with a cask end that has been turned into an original work of art by Turner Prize nominee Callum Innes. This was the first time that one of Diageo’s Casks of Distinction has been sold at auction.

The Glenfiddich 1950s Collection:
A one-off collection of bottles containing liquid from the last four remaining casks of Glenfiddich distilled in 1955, 1957, 1958 and 1959. These expressions are housed in a bespoke maple and mahogany cabinet made by Royal Warrant holder NEJ Stevenson and fitted with a thermometer and hygrometer from world-renowned instrument maker Fischer. The collection includes the following bottles: 66 Years Old (40.1% ABV, distilled 1955), 64 Years Old (43.3% ABV, distilled 1957), 63 Years Old (distilled 1958) and 62 Years Old (45.5% ABV, distilled 1959). The Collection sold for £1,037,500.
Magazine Archive

From the archive

Select an issue

Subscribe Now

Subscriptions for
Whisky Magazine are available
in print, digital or as a
complete package

The Benefits

8 print editions a year

Enjoy the convenience of home delivery

Full access to every digital edition via desktop, iOS or Android device

Latest Issue Subscribe Now

The Whisky Encyclopedia - Coming Soon 2024

Discover the world of whisky with our comprehensive encyclopedia
Featuring companies, distilleries, brands, glossaries, and cocktails

Join The Community

Sign up to the Whisky Magazine
newsletter letter and get access to the latest
in all things whisky

paragraph publishing ltd.   Copyright © 2024 all rights reserved.   Website by Acora One