The ascent of three great whiskies — Scotch, Irish, and American — was due to bigg, the often maligned and now marginalised barley variety.
Bigg comes from the Norse word bygg for barley. A Scandinavian six-row landrace, which the Vikings carried on their longboats and crossbred with North Britain and Ireland’s ancient six-row landraces introduced by Neolithic farmers. Six-rowed barley was also known as bere, bear, or square barley, as its extra barleycorn rows form an angular head.
Barley has the highest diastase of all cereals, meaning its hydrolytic enzymes, α- and β-amylase, cleave starches into maltose and glucose more efficiently, providing yeast with more sugars to convert into alcohol. Bigg’s smaller and more numerous kernels contain up to 25 per cent more enzymes than two-row barley, supplying a reproductive edge to survive harsher growing conditions. But bigg’s genetic legacy meant a smaller endosperm package, with more protein and husk and less cereal starch. A 1798 government study noted, “good bigg while in the state of raw grain, yields more spirits than an equal quantity of the best English barley.” Its secret lay in being a diastatic powerhouse that converts the starches of raw or unmalted cereals like oats, barley, rye, and wheat into fermentable sugars, and reducing manufacturing costs. For brewers and distillers, it was an invaluable and cheap malted cereal for mashing with adjunct grains.
Low-pH soils, disease tolerance, and cold climates originally suited the adaptation of six-row bigg landraces. Cultivated for livestock feed, foodstuffs, and household materials, bigg was first utilised for distillation in 14th-century Ireland and 15th-century Scotland. Bigg and oats remained important grains in Scotland. The introduction of improved barley varieties and advances in fermentation science eroded bigg’s historical dominance, allowing English and hybrid Scotch barley varieties to be cultivated beyond the Lowlands, contributing to bigg’s decline in the 19th century. A government report in 1804 described bigg in Scotland as being a “great part of the barley raised in our country consumed by distilleries”; by 1818, bigg was estimated to have fallen to 50 per cent of cultivation, falling to 10 per cent of barley area by 1850, to five per cent in 1912, and reduced to a mere 10 hectares in 1999.
The bulk importation of English two-row to newly-established capital Lowland distilleries in the late 18th century signalled the shift away from bigg. Even with bigg priced eight per cent to 14 per cent less than barley, and the malt tax reducing malted bigg to malted barley by 18 per cent to 23 per cent from 1803 to 1823, yields remained nine per cent to 24 per cent less alcohol per bushel, only offering a temporary respite for highland and island malt pot distilleries continuing to mash local bigg. By the late 19th century, revenue data reported that almost all Scottish pot distilleries had shifted to malted two-row barley, with Alfred Barnard reporting in 1887 that only two pot distilleries in Ireland mashed 100 per cent malted barley. The expression ‘single malt’, meaning 100 per cent malted barley, appeared as a trade term in the 1860s, but it did not gain legal status until 1990.
In North America, six-row barley thrived from the 17th century, fuelling America’s whiskey and beer industries, as two-row barley struggled to adapt to the climatic differences. Bigg’s diastatic power served as a crucial base for other adjunct grains in mash bills, especially corn and rye, in the manufacture of bourbon whiskey, rice, and corn for lager beers. Federal regulations permit distilleries to mash with exogenous industrial enzymes, especially thick mashes of gelatinised corn starch, which has allowed new varieties of two-row to supplant six-row since the 1960s to ferment smoother, richer flavours.
Early distillers observed the higher productivity of six-row barley in mixed mashes. However, the role of enzymes as chemical catalysts was not scientifically understood until the late 19th century; by then, each country’s distinctive whisky style was well established.