Taster

Nose: Citrussy and buttery. Orange curd. Earthy and musty. Moss, fern. Hint of rose.

Palate: Sweet at first, then gets close to medlars. Spices wipe out this unpleasant note.

Finish: Dry and spicy. Rather tangy.

Comment: Lacks balance. Alcohol is quite fierce. Water tames it down but needs to be strictly dosed as it enhances bitterness. Some character but quite sharp.

Score: 7.5

Taster

Nose: High-toned and estery but with a deep caramel toffee from the oak. Super-ripe fruits and a smoky edge.

Palate: Praline, runny toffee, sultana. Somewhat rum like: allspice, ginger, brazil nut, cool mint, rice crackers. Smoke hangs above like a veil.

Finish: Clean and gentle. Medium.

Comment: Perfume and smoke? It's a Japanese Ardmore.

Score: 8.3