Taster

Nose: Again, closely related to the Founder's Reserve. More vanilla, with the honey a degree lighter than some previous bottlings. Even so, this is just wonderful.

Palate: An explosion of bittersweet flavours. Incredible depth and complexity with the trademark Balvenie maltiness. Lots of spicy peat notes.

Finish: Amazingly long with some chewy smoke, even a hint of liquorice. Some chocolate for good measure.

Comment: Arguably the ultimate Speyside dram, though the Glenfiddich Solera gives it a close run. A kaleidoscope of flavours.

Score: 9.5

Taster

Nose: Assertive. Dry, fresh oak. Heather. Rooty. Coconut. Lemon pith.

Palate: Lively. Cedar. Orange skins, fruity, pineapple-like sweetness and acidity.

Finish: Very dry. Peppery alcohol.

Comment: Certainly robust. Perhaps a little harsh?

Score: 8