Taster

Nose: An unwelcome note of damp wood at start which gives way to wet straw then citrus fruit (orange pulp). Takes times to open up. Grated coconut.

Palate: Smooth at start then getting drier and slightly sour. Grippy oak, Touch of leather.

Finish: Dry, spicy (paprika).

Comment: Oak is prevailing, especially on the palate. Lacks balance and charm.

Score: 7.5

Taster

Nose: Warm. Cow's breath and sweet hay with a hint of scented smoke, lemon. Mature. Becomes fresher and greener in time, hedge clippings.

Palate: Clean, leafy with an acidic energy. Good orchard fruits in, then hazelnut and light smoke. Good balance.

Finish: Tight and slightly smoked.

Comment: Has maturity and presence. Ardmore: a complete package.

Score: 7.8